Thinking Out Loud

Friday, April 13, 2012

Much as I love a good rant, a clear explanation is even better

Somehow I missed this guest post on the always fantastic Opinio Juris: Glazier: More on Why the Al-Nashiri Charges Are Flawed:

'via Blog this'
Posted by Sarah L Boyd at 9:37 p.m. 1 comment:
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Newer Posts Older Posts Home
Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)

About Me

My photo
Sarah L Boyd
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
I'm a lawyer in Toronto with an unhealthy love of international criminal law and administrative work. Oh yes, and napping.
View my complete profile

Caveat Lector

I like a good argument like a starving wolf likes a bloody deer carcass. So, the basic rule is: Feel free to disagree, just don't be a jerk about it. This blog reflects my brain, always a work in progress. I'm not afraid to say what I think, but I can also admit when I'm wrong. Have I got my facts wrong? Correct me. Is my logic faulty? Show me. Know another perspective? Tell me. But please, please, for the love of God(s), be as prepared for a counter argument as you are for a capitulation. You can contact me here...

Search This Blog

Subscribe To

Posts
Atom
Posts
All Comments
Atom
All Comments

Friends

Twitter Updates

    follow me on Twitter

    My Sites

    • My Human Rights Law Resources Site
    • My Olde Tyme Blogge (LJ)
    • My YouTube Videos

    Blogroll

    • Language Log
      3 hours ago
    • Whatever
      1 day ago
    • Boing Boing
      2 months ago
    • WWdN: In Exile
      1 year ago
    • Ironic Sans
      4 years ago
    • Mind Hacks
      6 years ago
    • The Eggcorn Database - RSS2 Feed
      7 years ago
    • The “Blog” of “Unnecessary” Quotation Marks
      7 years ago
    • Joe. My. God.
      9 years ago
    • Center of Gravitas
      9 years ago
    • Kung Fu Monkey
      9 years ago
    • Bitch. Ph.D.
      13 years ago
    • The Cheapseats
      15 years ago
    • Please, Please, Let Them Have Picture Menus
      16 years ago
    • Overheard in the Office
    • Hanzi Smatter 一知半解
    • Overheard at York

    Blawg-roll

    • New Decisions : Supreme Court of Canada
      Quebec (Commission des droits de la personne et des droits de la jeunesse) v. Directrice de la protection de la jeunesse du CISSS A, 2024 SCC 43 (CanLII)
      2 days ago
    • The Court
      Privacy Commissioner v Facebook: Protecting Your Data From Tech Giants
      2 weeks ago
    • Law is Cool
      Can we balance work and our personal life?
      10 years ago
    • Solo in Ontario: Criminal Practice
      Solo in Ontario: Criminal Practice has moved!
      15 years ago
    • Overheard in Law School
      Ha Ha Ha...Ewww
      16 years ago
    • International Extradition Blog
    • International Crimes Blog
    • Opinio Juris

    I <3 Web Comics

    • xkcd.com
      Exclusion Principle
      2 days ago
    • Wondermark
      Requesting email newsletter advice!
      5 days ago
    • The Perry Bible Fellowship
      Invasion
      4 weeks ago
    • Octopus Pie
      Octopus Pie: The Complete Series Box Set – Coming in September 2023!
      1 year ago
    • Dinosaur Comics
      ironically writing this comic WAS a very productive hour for me, so things are looking up for ol' ryan
      5 years ago
    • Comics: Somethingpositive
      [SP] Opportunities
      6 years ago
    • Achewood
      End of Golden Tabloid
      7 years ago
    • FreakAngels
      Episode 0144
      13 years ago
    • indexed
      Indexed is moving!
      16 years ago
    • Lucid TV
    • Three Panel Soul
    • The FAIL Blog
    • The Official QC RSS Feed
    • I CAN HAS CHEEZBURGER?
    • Templar, Arizona

    Blog Archive

    • ►  2018 (2)
      • ►  November (1)
      • ►  September (1)
    • ►  2017 (5)
      • ►  December (1)
      • ►  March (4)
    • ►  2016 (3)
      • ►  December (3)
    • ►  2015 (1)
      • ►  March (1)
    • ►  2014 (4)
      • ►  July (1)
      • ►  June (3)
    • ▼  2012 (48)
      • ►  December (1)
      • ►  November (20)
      • ►  September (5)
      • ►  August (2)
      • ►  July (13)
      • ▼  April (1)
        • Much as I love a good rant, a clear explanation is...
      • ►  February (6)
    • ►  2011 (42)
      • ►  November (4)
      • ►  September (10)
      • ►  August (10)
      • ►  July (2)
      • ►  June (2)
      • ►  May (9)
      • ►  April (2)
      • ►  March (3)
    • ►  2010 (50)
      • ►  December (3)
      • ►  October (3)
      • ►  August (5)
      • ►  July (13)
      • ►  June (6)
      • ►  May (5)
      • ►  April (1)
      • ►  March (6)
      • ►  February (4)
      • ►  January (4)
    • ►  2009 (35)
      • ►  August (2)
      • ►  July (2)
      • ►  June (3)
      • ►  May (5)
      • ►  April (7)
      • ►  March (9)
      • ►  February (1)
      • ►  January (6)
    • ►  2008 (99)
      • ►  December (8)
      • ►  November (6)
      • ►  October (1)
      • ►  September (6)
      • ►  August (4)
      • ►  July (8)
      • ►  June (2)
      • ►  May (13)
      • ►  April (13)
      • ►  March (14)
      • ►  February (7)
      • ►  January (17)
    • ►  2007 (143)
      • ►  December (5)
      • ►  November (12)
      • ►  October (12)
      • ►  September (15)
      • ►  August (12)
      • ►  July (10)
      • ►  June (6)
      • ►  May (16)
      • ►  April (15)
      • ►  March (8)
      • ►  February (21)
      • ►  January (11)
    • ►  2006 (18)
      • ►  December (5)
      • ►  November (10)
      • ►  October (3)

    Tag!

    • news (46)
    • politics (41)
    • FC (37)
    • human rights (35)
    • humour (26)
    • foreign affairs (23)
    • law (23)
    • refugees (22)
    • Canada (21)
    • ethics (19)
    • identity politics (19)
    • religion (19)
    • culture (18)
    • credibility (14)
    • RPD (13)
    • gender issues (13)
    • immigration (13)
    • Israel (12)
    • PRRA (11)
    • history (11)
    • medicine (11)
    • evidence (10)
    • US (9)
    • sexuality (9)
    • Islam (8)
    • ignored evidence (8)
    • quotes (8)
    • state protection (8)
    • video (8)
    • If I had a million dollars (7)
    • UK (7)
    • YouTube (7)
    • blogs (7)
    • comics (7)
    • generalized risk (7)
    • Iran (6)
    • ON NOTICE (6)
    • UN (6)
    • civil rights (6)
    • language (6)
    • military (6)
    • philosophy (6)
    • reasons (6)
    • Conservatives (5)
    • IFA (5)
    • Iraq (5)
    • Mexico (5)
    • developing world (5)
    • domestic violence (5)
    • failure to deal with evidence (5)
    • humanitarian and compassionate (5)
    • links (5)
    • organ transplants (5)
    • China (4)
    • Harper (4)
    • IAD (4)
    • Language Log (4)
    • O'Keefe (4)
    • books (4)
    • computers (4)
    • movies (4)
    • psychology (4)
    • public health (4)
    • remedies (4)
    • sex workers (4)
    • stereotypes (4)
    • torture (4)
    • Afghanistan (3)
    • Africa (3)
    • Anglicans (3)
    • Arar (3)
    • Catholicism (3)
    • Christmas (3)
    • Colombia (3)
    • Dan Savage (3)
    • Gardasil (3)
    • Gender Guidelines (3)
    • ICTY (3)
    • Judaism (3)
    • PHRASE OF THE DAY (3)
    • Quebec (3)
    • Russell (3)
    • Zinn (3)
    • best interests of the child (3)
    • compassionate (3)
    • country conditions (3)
    • death (3)
    • detention review (3)
    • dhimmi (3)
    • e-mail forwards (3)
    • elections (3)
    • fairness (3)
    • humanitarian (3)
    • ignored ground (3)
    • inadequate reasons (3)
    • inadmissibility (3)
    • international criminal law (3)
    • international relations (3)
    • mandamus (3)
    • medical inadmissibility (3)
    • nationality (3)
    • psychological assessment (3)
    • quizzes (3)
    • relevant evidence (3)
    • section 97 (3)
    • transitional justice (3)
    • AIDS (2)
    • BAILII (2)
    • Belgium (2)
    • DCO (2)
    • FCA (2)
    • Galway (2)
    • HC (2)
    • HPV (2)
    • ICC (2)
    • ICC Summer School (2)
    • ICJ (2)
    • ICTR (2)
    • Kurds (2)
    • LAWYERED (2)
    • Liberals (2)
    • Minister's application denied (2)
    • Ministerial relief (2)
    • Ontario (2)
    • Opinio Juris (2)
    • Osgoode (2)
    • Serbia (2)
    • Shore (2)
    • Supreme Court (2)
    • TB (2)
    • Turkey (2)
    • UNHCR (2)
    • WHO (2)
    • art (2)
    • biodiversity (2)
    • biological determinism (2)
    • birthdays (2)
    • blogging (2)
    • children (2)
    • circular logic (2)
    • citizenship (2)
    • conscientious objection (2)
    • contextual analysis (2)
    • corroborating evidence (2)
    • de Montigny (2)
    • detention (2)
    • disclosure (2)
    • discrimination (2)
    • drugs (2)
    • education (2)
    • excessive demand (2)
    • family (2)
    • fun (2)
    • genocide (2)
    • genuine marriage (2)
    • globalization (2)
    • hardship (2)
    • hijabs (2)
    • house church (2)
    • internets (2)
    • interpretation (2)
    • irrelevant considerations (2)
    • legal writing (2)
    • membership (2)
    • meme (2)
    • misconstrued evidence (2)
    • new PRRA evidence (2)
    • new evidence (2)
    • objective evidence (2)
    • particularized risk (2)
    • plausibility (2)
    • rehabilitation (2)
    • safe country of origin (2)
    • same-sex marriage (2)
    • shari'a (2)
    • sharia (2)
    • standard of review (2)
    • translation (2)
    • travel (2)
    • victim of crime (2)
    • writing (2)
    • xkcd (2)
    • 2006 (1)
    • Abdelrazik (1)
    • Abu Ghraib (1)
    • Albania (1)
    • Amnesty Int'l (1)
    • Annis (1)
    • Arar Commission (1)
    • Australia (1)
    • Boivin (1)
    • Bolivia (1)
    • Boswell (1)
    • Bush (1)
    • CBSA (1)
    • CIDT (1)
    • CSIS (1)
    • California (1)
    • Celil (1)
    • Chomsky (1)
    • Christian (1)
    • Cuba (1)
    • DADT (1)
    • DRC (1)
    • Democratic Republic of the Congo (1)
    • Dresden (1)
    • Dublin Regulations (1)
    • ECHR (1)
    • EWCA (1)
    • Egypt (1)
    • El Salvador (1)
    • Eritrea (1)
    • European Commission (1)
    • European Union (1)
    • Even when you win you lose (1)
    • FARC (1)
    • GPO (1)
    • Good Works (1)
    • Greece (1)
    • Green Party (1)
    • Guyana (1)
    • HCs (1)
    • HIV (1)
    • HRW (1)
    • Heneghan (1)
    • Hijinks Ensue (1)
    • Hinzman (1)
    • House MD (1)
    • I heart things (1)
    • ID (1)
    • IRPA s. 48 (1)
    • Immigration Division (1)
    • January 2012 (1)
    • Journal (1)
    • Key Quote (1)
    • Koran (1)
    • Kosovo (1)
    • Louise Arbour (1)
    • Mac (1)
    • Maclean's (1)
    • Maher Arar (1)
    • Mandaeans (1)
    • Mandamin (1)
    • Mark Steyn (1)
    • Mavi Marmara (1)
    • Mobil Oil (1)
    • Mosley (1)
    • Nicaragua (1)
    • O'Connor Commission (1)
    • PC (1)
    • PKK (1)
    • PTSD (1)
    • Pakistan (1)
    • Palestine (1)
    • Phelan (1)
    • Pickton (1)
    • Qur'an (1)
    • Quran (1)
    • Rabbi Elior Chen (1)
    • Raoul Wallenberg Symposium (1)
    • Rennie (1)
    • Republicans (1)
    • Ribic (1)
    • Roma (1)
    • Rowan Williams (1)
    • Rumsfeld (1)
    • Russia (1)
    • Rwanda (1)
    • Saddam Hussein (1)
    • Saudi Arabia (1)
    • Scott (1)
    • Sikhism (1)
    • Slaw.ca (1)
    • Somalia (1)
    • South Dakota (1)
    • Stephen King (1)
    • Strickland (1)
    • Sudan (1)
    • Supernatural (1)
    • TRPs (1)
    • The Walrus (1)
    • Toronto (1)
    • Twitter (1)
    • UK Supreme Court (1)
    • UKSC (1)
    • US Constitution (1)
    • US First Amendment (1)
    • Uganda (1)
    • Umberto Eco (1)
    • Vancouver (1)
    • WWII (1)
    • Yerodia (1)
    • abortion (1)
    • academia (1)
    • accents (1)
    • adequate reasons (1)
    • administrative law (1)
    • airplanes (1)
    • architecture (1)
    • blood feud (1)
    • bolstering (1)
    • burial (1)
    • burka/burqa (1)
    • clarification (1)
    • comparative law (1)
    • constitution (1)
    • consular protection (1)
    • coverups (1)
    • de facto family (1)
    • decision (1)
    • declaration of ability and intent (1)
    • deferral (1)
    • design (1)
    • direction from the Court (1)
    • draft (1)
    • durable change (1)
    • effective change (1)
    • equivalency (1)
    • espionage (1)
    • evidence from agent of persecution (1)
    • exclusion (1)
    • extradition (1)
    • failure to follow test (1)
    • fairness letter (1)
    • faith-based schools (1)
    • falun gong (1)
    • fettered discretion (1)
    • fgm (1)
    • forward-looking (1)
    • fraudulent documents (1)
    • free speech (1)
    • freedom of speech (1)
    • gang (1)
    • geekery (1)
    • geography (1)
    • grad school (1)
    • grudge (1)
    • hardship test (1)
    • health (1)
    • hearing (1)
    • heightened risk (1)
    • hostile decision maker (1)
    • immigration detention (1)
    • immunity (1)
    • index (1)
    • inevitable result (1)
    • inquiry (1)
    • internal flight alternative (1)
    • judge (1)
    • landing (1)
    • language requirement (1)
    • layout (1)
    • lex talionis (1)
    • lolcats (1)
    • marriage equality (1)
    • mental health (1)
    • mootness (1)
    • municipal law (1)
    • nexus (1)
    • niqab (1)
    • nomenclature (1)
    • notice (1)
    • organized crime (1)
    • particular circumstances (1)
    • particular social group (1)
    • passport (1)
    • personalized risk (1)
    • persuasive decision (1)
    • photos (1)
    • political ground (1)
    • presumption of truth (1)
    • privilege (1)
    • probe (1)
    • procedural fairness (1)
    • profanity (1)
    • prosecution versus persecution (1)
    • re-open (1)
    • reasonable efforts (1)
    • recommendations (1)
    • refoulement (1)
    • rehearing by same decision maker (1)
    • reme (1)
    • reopen (1)
    • reviews (1)
    • risk (1)
    • security (1)
    • security certificates (1)
    • sentencing (1)
    • separation of powers (1)
    • serious non-political crime (1)
    • settlements (1)
    • sexual assault/rape (1)
    • shingles (1)
    • skilled worker (1)
    • sociology (1)
    • software (1)
    • sponsorship (1)
    • standard of proof (1)
    • stay of removal (1)
    • stem cells (1)
    • sterilization (1)
    • student visa (1)
    • sur place (1)
    • tea (1)
    • television (1)
    • temporary work permit (1)
    • terms and conditions (1)
    • test (1)
    • totality of the evidence (1)
    • unreliable evidence (1)
    • ur doin' it wrong (1)
    • vendetta (1)
    • veterans (1)
    • waterboarding (1)
    • webcomic (1)
    • weighing evidence (1)
    • whistleblower (1)

    Pages of Interest

    • American Rhetoric (online speech bank)
    • Amnesty International
    • Boing Boing: A Directory of Wonderful Things
    • Engrish
    • Great Speeches Collection
    • Human Rights Watch
    • Kristy vs the Zombie Army (webcomic)
    • Osgoode Hall Law Journal
    • Osgoode Hall Law School (York University, Toronto)
    • Queen of Wands (webcomic)
    • Questionable Content (webcomic)
    • Slate e-zine
    • Something Positive (webcomic)
    • The Adventures of Dr. McNinja (webcomic)
    • The Court (Osgoode Hall's SCC Site)
    • Top 100 Speeches in American History
    • Toronto Star
    • Walrus Magazine
    • Wondermark (webcomic)
    • xkcd: A webcomic of romance, sarcasm, math, and language.
    Simple theme. Powered by Blogger.