Showing posts with label Colombia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Colombia. Show all posts

Sunday, July 15, 2012

Delgado Ruiz—ignored evidence that persecutors would continue to pursue

Delgado Ruiz v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2012 FC 163 (CanLII)

Judge: Justice Harrington; Date heard: January 31, 2012; Date decided: February 7, 2012; Counsel for Delgado Ruiz: Cristina Marinelli; Counsel for Minister: Daniel Baum; Place of Hearing: Montréal, Quebec.

The applicants were citizens of Colombia, and the principal applicant worked for the Colombian Embassy in Guatemala, at which position she began receiving threats from members of FARC and Maras to force her to provide documents to their members. When she refused and left her position at the Embassy, she was the victim of further threats and shots were fired at her (paras. 1-2).

The Refugee Protection Division found that the applicants had no status in Guatemala. They further found that while the principal applicant had been in danger, the danger would now have dissipated given the time passed and since she no longer worked for the Colombian government and therefore had nothing they wanted (paras. 3-4).

Justice Harrington found that while the RPD’s conclusion had some logic to it, i.e. that FARC wouldn’t care about the principal applicant anymore, the conclusion ignored evidence before the RPD that FARC would continue to pursue former targets as perceived class enemies regardless of the passage of time (paras. 8-9). Therefore, the RPD fell into the error described in Cepeda-Gutierrez v Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration), 157 FTR 35, [1998] FCJ No 1425 of failing to confront contradictory evidence (para. 10)

Friday, September 30, 2011

Oliveros Rubiano—no need to exhaust state protection if reasonable efforts made

Oliveros Rubiano v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2011 FC 106 (CanLII)

Judge: Justice O’Keefe

Date heard: September 22, 2010

Date decided: February 2, 2011

Counsel for Oliveros Rubiano: Jonathan E. Fedder

Counsel for Minister: Kareena Wilding & Veronica Cham

Place of Hearing: Toronto, Ontario

Decision Under Review: negative pre-removal risk assessment

The Applicant fled Colombia with his family, after having become the target of an extortion scheme by the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC), and having reported it to the Colombian army (para. 4). He suffered detention, threats, the murder of family members, and in 2005 he himself was shot, which he reported (paras. 4-5). The family fled to Ecuador in September 2005, but upon finding out that there was no assistance with food, shelter, or legal counsel, the returned to Colombia (para. 6).

In April 2006, the Applicant and his family entered the United States as visitors (para. 7). They travelled to the Canadian border but the Applicant was denied eligibility to make a refugee claim in Canada because of the Safe Third Country Agreement. He applied for but was refused asylum in the US, and he subsequently crossed the border illegally and made a claim in Canada which was also refused (para. 7).

In November 20098 the Applicant filed a pre-removal risk assessment application and expressly requested an oral hearing (para. 8).

The officer found that the Applicant had not submitted sufficient evidence that he had been or was targeted, or that he had a similar situation to his cousins who had been murdered (paras. 9-10). The officer gave little weight to the affidavits of his mother and cousins, finding that they were interested parties and that their evidence was not supported by the objective evidence (para. 11). The officer found the Applicant had not demonstrated subjective fear, in that he had returned to Colombia from Ecuador (para. 12). Furthermore, the Applicant still had family in Colombia who had not been targeted, and failed to show a lack of state protection (paras. 13-14).

Citing Farias (Farias v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration),2008 FC 1035, cited at para. 34), Katwaru (Katwaru v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) 2007 FC 612, cited at para. 35), and Gilvaja (Gilvaja v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration), 2009 FC 598 cited at para. 38) Justice O’Keefe found that the PRRA officer had “erred in law by requiring the applicant to show that he had exhausted all avenues of state protection”, since the Applicant had shown that he had made reasonable efforts to no avail (para. 39).

JUDICIAL REVIEW ALLOWED

Friday, October 01, 2010

Diaz – refugee board fails in credibility analysis

Diaz v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2010 FC 797

In a case of a family from Colombia, Justice Zinn found that the RPD’s decision on negative credibility could not stand. The principal applicant testified that she could not be sure if the agents of persecution were FARC or a drug cartel, but this was not relevant to an assessment of risk under s. 97 (para. 19). The Board could have found her testimony regarding the murder of her husband’s co-worker to be not relevant, since she was not sure of the perpetrator, but the Board was wrong to call this “embellishment” (para. 20). The Board also made several straightforward factual errors, which while not reviewable in and of themselves, “cast some doubt on the thoroughness and accuracy of the Board’s assessment in its totality” (para 21). The Board focussed on whether or not FARC was targeting the applicants, to the exclusion of a complete analysis of the case and the risks. The Board also erred in finding there was an IFA to Colombia. Finally, the Board relied on cases and on the argument that the applicants were exposed to generalized risk, but failed to make an explicit finding of generalized risk.

Judge: Justice Zinn

Date decided: August 4, 2010

Counsel: Jack Davis for Applicants, Ladan Shahrooz for Minister.