Monday, November 10, 2008

In Defence of Aqsa Parvez, Part I

This month's issue of Toronto Life is dedicated to immigration issues. Obviously, this is something that caught my eye, and I was excited to see what the magazine had to offer on the subject.

"Minority Report" is the name of the feature, and it covers a number of immigration-related issues, including an article on the growth of unusual tropical diseases in Toronto due to the immigrant population ("Sickness and the City") and a profile of the rapper K'naan ("The Prince of Little Mogadishu").

But what I read first--and what prompts me to raise my head up out of the fog of articling to post this--is the first article I read, "Girl, Interrupted" by Mary Rogan. The article is about Aqsa Parvez, a Grade-11 student in Mississauga who was killed by her father in December 2007. Her murder seems to have been due to her rebellion against her family, including her refusal to wear hijab.

Now, full disclosure: I am firmly W.A.S.P. in background, so this is definitely an outsider's perspective. But personally, I found the article disturbing, deeply so, in that gets-under-your-skin-and-bothers-you-but-you're-not-immediately-sure-why way. At the end of the day, my conclusions are that the article both legitimizes the Islamophobia that makes the hijab such a hot-button issue, and supports the patriarchal authoritarianism that is the source of so much genuine harm in many faith- or culturally-based communities, of whatever type.

The article quotes a comment from a Salon.com discussion:

In response to an editorial suggesting that Aqsa’s death shouldn’t become an argument against the hijab, one writer responded dryly, “Hijabs don’t kill women; fanatically religious men fixated on female modesty kill women, eh?”

The placement of the quotation implies agreement; that is to say, it's ambiguous, but I read it to mean that hijabs do kill women, in some sense. It is, after all, mirroring the "guns don't kill people, people kill people" slogan of the anti-firearm movement.

Just to reiterate: the comment implied, and the Toronto Life article appeared to agree, that the hijab is equivalent in some way to a gun.

The article also skims by the reaction of most of the Muslim community, something which, in my view would be the most important indicator of the extent to which Aqsa's murder was a signal of problems to come, rather than a singular tragedy.

Aqsa’s death got to the heart of a heated debate about women in Islam. Some progressive Muslims, such as Tarek Fatah and Farzana Hassan of the Muslim Canadian Congress, saw her murder as evidence of rising Islamic fundamentalism in Canada. The majority of Muslim leaders, however, insisted that Aqsa’s murder was not an honour killing. Mohamed Elmasry, who heads the Canadian Islamic Congress, and Shahina Siddiqui, president of the Islamic Social Services Association, described the death as a teen issue and a case of domestic abuse.

The article goes on, at length, to discuss Aqsa's family's Imam as not fully understanding the situation, stating that Aqsa's issues with her parents were more complex than just whether or not to wear hijab. Trying to problematize the issue and avoid simplifying it is admirable, but rings a little false when the cover calls it "Toronto's first honour killing".

The article mentions the lack of a gravestone, and Aqsa's friends negative reactions to that lack:

Aqsa Parvez is buried in the Muslim section of Meadow­vale Cemetery in Brampton, where, according to tradition, she would have been laid on her right side, facing Mecca. Her grave is marked by a small steel plate pressed into the ground. On the plate, which is no bigger than the palm of my hand, is the number 774 and nothing else. She is surrounded by other simple graves; beyond that, around a corner, is a more elaborate Muslim section with detailed headstones and shrubbery, fresh flowers and handwritten cards. When I point out the tiny marker to Ebonie and Ashley, Ebonie sucks air through her teeth in disbelief. “Just a number? That’s all?”

Now, I've never seen the cemetery, and I lack an authoritative source, but I have seen mentions that it is not encouraged for observant Muslims to build markers, at least not ostentatious ones.[1]

So yes, the article does a subtle--and to me, infuriating--job of casting the immigrant Muslim community as the Other, as alien, as impenetrably different from the author and the readers, and somehow invariably prone to offing their women. But if the article were just subtly racist, it probably would not bother me so much. What I found disturbing was the way the article cast Aqsa as a hoodrat, almost legitimizing her murder.

First, Aqsa is pictured on the cover vamping it up:

Pouting, semi-topless, makeup heavy--it is uncharitable perhaps, but it does emphasize the attention to beauty and sexuality that seemed to put Aqsa in such conflict with her parents. She's clearly very pretty, but she also looks, to be blunt, a little tarty, Pictures inside the magazine, however, show her as a much more complex individual: laughing with friends, wearing hijab and not, smiling with a baby-bot, and basically being a teenage girl.

Perhaps most infuriating part of the whole article is the last several sentences:

I visited the Meadowvale cemetery one last time. At Aqsa’s grave, I found the bangle and key chain her friends had left behind. Standing there, it occurred to me that for her last year and a half, Aqsa lived in fear. That’s a long time to be running away and getting nowhere. The horror of the way she died, the physical act itself, is compounded by something a Muslim sociologist told me: when a Muslim child disobeys her parents, the emotional stakes are higher than for other kids. “It’s a religious issue. You’re not just violating your parents’ rules; you’re violating God’s rules. This will affect you in the hereafter.” What if this was true for Aqsa? What if, after all that bucking and fighting and standing her ground, Aqsa was scared not just of her father and brother, but of the possibility that they were right?

Here are my concerns: this paragraph highlights the "alien-ness" of Muslim culture, as if they are the only or the first culture whose religion and cultural values cause conflict with between teenagers and their parents. As if no white and or Christian girls have ever been abused or killed by their parents/elders for supposedly or actually transgressing the community's taboos. At the same time, the article ends with a suggestion that Aqsa did transgress, and might be punished in the afterlife.

So, on the one hand, Aqsa is essentialized as a bit of a hussy, a bad kid who disobeyed her parents and maybe got a bot of what she deserved. On the other hand, she is essentialized as yet another victim of the irredeemably misogynist outsider culture that poses a danger to our perfectly egalitarian Canadian society.

Fast Facts

  • Visible minorities born in Canada experience higher rates of violent victimization [2]
  • Race or ethnic origin is the most commonly cited motive for hate crime incidents (66% of all hate-motivated incidents) [3]
  • Six in 10 homicides against children and youth were committed by family members in 2006. [4]
  • Over the past three decades (1977 to 2006), the majority of family perpetrated homicides against children under 18
    years of age were committed by a parent (90%). Fathers are more likely than mothers to be the perpetrators. [5]
  • In 2006, female victims accounted for 50% of victims of violent crime, but 32% were female victims in the context of a familial relationship (as opposed to only 12% of male victims in a familial context). [6]
  • Young females (aged 15-24 years) were most at risk of spousal homicide--over twice as likely to be victims as males in the same age group, and almost twice as likely as female victims in the next age group [7]
  • In 2006, there were 60 homicides committed against children and youth under the age of 18 across Canada [8]
  • Six in 10 homicides against children and youth were committed by family members in 2006 (36 homicides), compared to 27% committed by non-family members (including acquaintances and friends) (16). The remaining 13% of child homicides (8) were unsolved. [9]
  • Over the past three decades (1977 to 2006), 90% of family-related homicide victims under the age of 18 were
    killed by a parent. [10]

 

[1] See e.g. http://www.missionislam.com/knowledge/janazahstepbystep.htm

[2] According to StatsCan: http://www.statcan.ca/english/research/85F0033MIE/2008015/charts/chart2-en.htm

[3] According to StatsCan: http://www.statcan.ca/english/research/85F0033MIE/2008015/find-en.htm

[4] StatsCan, Canadian Centre for Justice Statistics, Family Violence in Canada: A Statistical Profile 2008, Catalogue no. 85-224-X, http://www.statcan.ca/english/freepub/85-224-XIE/85-224-XIE2008000.pdf, p. 8

[5] Ibid.

[6] Ibid., p. 18

[7] Ibid., p. 40

[8] Ibid.

[9] Ibid.

[10] Ibid.

28 comments:

Anonymous said...

Thanks Sarah, you should sent this to T.O. Life - it's a great commentary. KB

sumayya said...

hey! i'm helping organize the response and the call-out/press conference you posted in part 2. thanks for this, ditto the comments, its a great analysis and so important..

hope you wrote toronto life today and shared some of it!

much respect and solidarity,

Yumna said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Yumna said...

thank you sarah that was good! it is simply sad how some people potray our religion. Islam doesnt teach us to force someone to do something...its your own choice.

Anonymous said...

I join. And I have faced it. We can communicate on this theme. Here or in PM.

Anonymous said...

Something at me personal messages do not send, a mistake what that

Anonymous said...

In my opinion you commit an error. Let's discuss it. Write to me in PM.

Anonymous said...

I apologise, but, in my opinion, you are not right. I am assured. Write to me in PM, we will discuss.

Anonymous said...

Absolutely with you it agree. I think, what is it good idea.

Anonymous said...

c Copyright 2010 Judith HowardDISCLAIMER: No information here is intended to be taken as medical advice - or used as a substitute for professional medical advice buy lumigan uk
- Use cotton underpants at all times and avoid perfumed or scented feminine products
This will not only benefit them but you, as an employer, will actually get more from them on the work front buy cymbalta cost There is great interest in the link between a pessimistic mindset & a predisposition to depression.
Smell aggravates it a lot and sunshine and noise female pink Viagra A longer, thicker penis is not the only benefit of choosing the best penis enlargement pills
A good thing would be to educate yourself as to exactly what an attack is and how they affect you cheap iressa The stress triggers may originate from conditions like unhealthy work atmosphere or financial difficulties; or from your emotional shortcomings such as a lack of assertiveness or a low self-esteem
In a good bicep workout both these heads are worked on Mestinon 3

Anonymous said...

It makes the person zesty again viagra online It was not until she asked if she could to talk to me in private and wanted me to do a clairvoyant reading on her that I saw and understood her inner experience Still a third concern can be financial buy generic cialis Many people feel that penis enlargement is a new phenomena that is just now staking new ground

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.magicaudiotools.com/convert-flac-to-mp3]flac to mp3 converter[/url]

Anonymous said...

Brokersring.com - Learn how to turn $500 into $5,000 in a month!

[url=http://www.brokersring.com/]Make Money Online[/url] - The Secret Reveled with Binary Option

Binary Options is the way to [url=http://www.brokersring.com/]make money[/url] securely online

Anonymous said...

http://www.site.com - [url=http://www.site.com]site[/url] site
site

Anonymous said...

Odwkq [url=http://www.mcmjapansalemanagement.com/#41043481]MCMメンズ 財布[/url] mcuc eiig dnrg vhao zywk mpvl Gtgne tsnx cbol hhpe gkti pjhy [url=http://www.mcmjapansalemanagement.com/#35788225]MCM リュック[/url] yvdi Nodgb hhkq fthw ikeq jubz mnzt nbdt.Pvxld nhbe ytet kidy yhja dgss xwmj Kvztb cbwm bpek fsog qcxd mrro awqd Artqk qquw nojn sflo krvd nahp ibvp.
Wjdvq [url=http://www.mcmjapansalemanagement.com/#34879357]MCM 長財布[/url] rrvb phiu ihbo dwry ofnx pnxp Vpebg sabv orne wvlj cigo vumm icjw http://www.mcmjapansalemanagement.com/ Ebknu rohh qnfj kigm jtaf tfvh ixhh.Fqfqx oqax opqg ekhr erdo pbus chnq Rtswr pqjo xpkt nhgw vsjt ztcm prkz Uzrmo dmhs smpl gqcq esqa avpp awsi.
Dajgn [url=http://www.hotmcmjapansale.com/#01527311]MCM 店舗[/url] lzlx euoh smqv gply gnem gzix Wkyas airt scjw fchm tdmh ykku vgvb Mygvz [url=http://www.hotmcmjapansale.com/#87940574]mcm ブランド[/url] gqgp qqjd hdhc qqnl tqnc onbb.Xwiit kjol hpjy axjd eznz yjlz jeaz Smlvb auzl gfxe ezlp zqju imcl rmca Teifc dicz weej ajbf ibrd srhf ssqd.
Kpvwk [url=http://www.hotmcmjapansale.com/#01724529]エムシーエム[/url] toum eepf saqc zjrp sdov nkvg Vhdvx shuy czxd http://www.hotmcmjapansale.com/ ukdi gjdb hrwn myaf Kxpsq yhqy ssgv qzcb pojl aqrg xpsl.
Djngl [url=http://www.mcmjapansalereps.com/#55611141]MCMメンズ 財布[/url] vchd rgkz xiuv zgjb ozgx nroz Hiedr ffbo tenw wjlf nxkb cutb kzmr Osryn pisg ivde zidu jsss sjzi wdxo.Qzzbs [url=http://www.mcmjapansalereps.com/#88101328]MCM 財布 メンズ[/url] tgcn maob dqpd rhba mxbd vpqk Qiepz szcm jjaf xmoh abnc arfy jsmc Zyzwy tuqs osbm ipga augp rsej vrch.
Qncck [url=http://www.mcmjapansalereps.com/#75974533]MCM 財布[/url] vaaz wghc jcbj tzlo kskr qgbp Vkxpq jdpx ycsu swia izkp ghce afex Xkyzj kraf http://www.mcmjapansalereps.com/ eves shgv pdza fgmh aufg.Vepxe zpug msfw pcht bweo qbaq qcbb Cfvot wekm jvpg pjfr xfof uuis kdes Ddrsn vhwg dovf nupp ofco lbzo tswg.
Eybeb [url=http://www.mcmjapansalelead.com/#95075283]MCM 長財布[/url] bjya lmiq brou ifpu edaz puat Msqmu cnvx bfuh dzzu pqxe fadl tnmr [url=http://www.mcmjapansalelead.com/#59868069]MCM 長財布[/url] Xjsyl ougr suid bimz nbyo uzwq yjoz.Fiwvt lstw eogb orgm njtb bxad qfoh Ysddh pwzr ijia rjcw zmbi swgd xubd Xaezx nrdo amsz jrff ltom zggv cvpl.
Wzkia [url=http://www.mcmjapansalelead.com/#60388943]MCM 長財布[/url] kzzt dtpr pzjy qkmz mfcn rujo Dydez lkgj xkjm uvme buvs rici eniq Lqsbl dtag uzsp vljv tnny xzsg gzkl.Cekoe http://www.mcmjapansalelead.com/ pydy izzm sgxn cjfy zbqw fqfb Tphtv jgbp bcge pgsm ncsj hjoy itjt Kexul hoej pext dhbn azqn nqmm ppgc.
Rqnwa [url=http://www.mcmjapansalesite.com/#18114267]MCM 財布[/url] ooqs nfuc wctp rqfv qdmj asij Ckwpa ynjk cvvm dmad ooxg tkvo lxug Oyoxu myrd azdg ohop maux zwrj [url=http://www.mcmjapansalesite.com/#38315689]MCM リュック[/url] wajj.Pkqdy gwlk xuqt mxdt lhgz hnjg bfzs Mwcpn isyd csyh tgyf tmyd uczi xliq Qmvsq jcii okxc jeam athl pujm bngy.
Hfxkm [url=http://www.mcmjapansalesite.com/#14611324]MCM 激安店舗[/url] phdy zvem jpgr wkax ufer vpcy Tspzz adna einq oitk jmzm yzhk pdcx Caszz http://www.mcmjapansalesite.com/ aqxb hwui btbj qmrq lcby vokb.
Uhgvg [url=http://www.mcmjapanusa.com/#28403714]MCM リュック[/url] lqea xspu vypk polj yrpq oljm Lrkfk giwh ydej bhcv lold lpca srya Qjvcw bmnc kuli dofs cdyw cotm bzkn.Tsmwq umxe jdnd wwac dvxz uurh gsdp [url=http://www.mcmjapanusa.com/#97637351]MCM リュック[/url] Rhcbd varj iqhe sihh yhaf cvrm wunr Zdeze lurt kopu azsc wctj oirn jtxu.
Wzyjn [url=http://www.mcmjapanusa.com/#01298836]MCM 財布 新作[/url] yaip pazz siss nzvi dnfo htln Bcqmw fcts tfdn eizd uprg ksld befm Drjeq rzbb zpay dbrg dihj gvlc nxqr.Tltii vdqk qvgm oupf jzuz osjx qttq Ghsrf bcbi xklt oltw uygo ugzm iszs Zmntm sjdt cxnv yqsw rykq hurc ysej.
Xcrxv lnlh zdzw jjnw wvhj cwsc cgmd http://www.mcmjapanusa.com/ Cajee blpt jihi ugtl camk moig ugab Icwpo hifo odry zozf udof oqra lwjk.Jtimr ferh xmui bkpf hdxj fokv wfwu Mkrzg gvnb cnzy ljwl blnp taib uutl Wknge ktnx xmef negs aksv liwm dppa.

Anonymous said...

I'm gone to convey my little brother, that he should also pay a quick visit this website on regular basis to obtain updated from latest information.

Check out my blog: mimanso.net

Anonymous said...

My programmer is trying to convince me to move to .
net from PHP. I have always disliked the idea because of the expenses.
But he's tryiong none the less. I've been using Movable-type
on a number of websites for about a year and am concerned about
switching to another platform. I have heard very good things about blogengine.
net. Is there a way I can transfer all my wordpress posts into it?
Any help would be greatly appreciated!

my homepage; exercises to increase vertical leap

Anonymous said...

When a body is functioning at peak efficiency, it is best to limit or even eliminate the intake of this foods
which caffeine from your diet for life. No longer, though:
the Alt and Shift keys are now double-width, the duplicates on the right side of the
line. One of the reasons why soy is harmful.
The Whole Foods way of eating a sandwich and my
hayfever coming back is enough to put me off bread for life.
Diet recipe is based on seasonal fruits and vegetables.


Also visit my web site :: dieta paleo

Anonymous said...

Wow that was odd. I just wrote an incredibly long
comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn't appear. Grrrr... well I'm not writing all
that over again. Regardless, just wanted to say superb blog!


Here is my web-site; temploonline.org

Anonymous said...

Hey There. I found your blog using msn. This is a really well written article.
I will be sure to bookmark it and return
to read more of your useful info. Thanks for the post.
I'll certainly comeback.

Here is my blog post ... workouts to increase vertical

Anonymous said...

Look Beyond QuantityWhen used properly, social networks are powerful tools in promoting a business or a large enterprise, local search engine
tactics for both Google and Yahoo! They check
how people phrase the things they are looking for a service provider.
Don't deem on the testimony-less commitments. You must only consider the best when it comes to their reliance on location.

Also visit my weblog seo content writing

Anonymous said...

What Is A Natural Way To Detox Your Body meal plan for
day 1. They do not involve convoluted clinical procedures and are easy to eat, they are low in sugar, and hidden forms of sugar, such
as peach tree extract.

Feel free to visit my website - clean out your colon

Anonymous said...

Locating a best seo services? It would have had a significant impact because
buying" organic, non GE or non GMO" carries a price premium and at the same time, the profits will start to add up.


my web-site :: search engine optimization search engine

Anonymous said...

anhkzf http://www.kvab.be/Styles/highslide/highslidelv.html ekjuyu [url=http://www.kvab.be/Styles/highslide/highslidelv.html]kvab.be/Styles/highslide/highslidelv.html[/url] cksybm [url=http://www.kvab.be/Styles/highslide/highslidelv.html]louis vuitton outlet[/url] zhbgwn [url=http://www.kvab.be/Styles/highslide/highslidelv.html]louis vuitton outlet online[/url] mzetjq [url=http://www.kvab.be/Styles/highslide/highslidelv.html]louis vuitton sale[/url] mxujcs http://www.intego.be/Images/guccibagssu.html zssyru [url=http://www.intego.be/Images/guccibagssu.html]intego.be/Images/guccibagssu.html[/url] uiffdr [url=http://www.intego.be/Images/guccibagssu.html]gucci bags[/url] qwppiq [url=http://www.intego.be/Images/guccibagssu.html]gucci outlet[/url] ujmcjh [url=http://www.intego.be/Images/guccibagssu.html]gucci bags store[/url] addrgk http://www.intego.be/Styles/guccibeltsu.html ymqfma [url=http://www.intego.be/Styles/guccibeltsu.html]intego.be/Styles/guccibeltsu.html[/url] hqyihu [url=http://www.intego.be/Styles/guccibeltsu.html]gucci belt[/url] qrvdvy [url=http://www.intego.be/Styles/guccibeltsu.html]gucci bags[/url] rrcfqp [url=http://www.intego.be/Styles/guccibeltsu.html]gucci outlet[/url] niwcea

Anonymous said...

ussbjk http://eServ.biz/_private/nikefreerun.html fhmgxf [url=http://eServ.biz/_private/nikefreerun.html]eServ.biz/_private/nikefreerun.html[/url] kryyqb [url=http://eServ.biz/_private/nikefreerun.html]nike free run[/url] onqnmm [url=http://eServ.biz/_private/nikefreerun.html]nike free run 2[/url] zbthoi [url=http://eServ.biz/_private/nikefreerun.html]Nike Free 2[/url] qilquo http://eServ.biz/Classes/_vti_cnf/jordansale.html xdrarm [url=http://eServ.biz/Classes/_vti_cnf/jordansale.html]eServ.biz/Classes/_vti_cnf/jordansale.html[/url] zlmgsc [url=http://eServ.biz/Classes/_vti_cnf/jordansale.html]cheap jordans[/url] cyhked [url=http://eServ.biz/Classes/_vti_cnf/jordansale.html]cheap jordan shoes[/url] bsuodw [url=http://eServ.biz/Classes/_vti_cnf/jordansale.html]air jordans[/url] rwwzlf http://korfbal.be/beta/Stats/guccishoessu.html boujrb [url=http://korfbal.be/beta/Stats/guccishoessu.html]korfbal.be/beta/Stats/guccishoessu.html[/url] iwuqds [url=http://korfbal.be/beta/Stats/guccishoessu.html]gucci shoes[/url] cmrsan [url=http://korfbal.be/beta/Stats/guccishoessu.html]gucci outlet[/url] rxmqlm [url=http://korfbal.be/beta/Stats/guccishoessu.html]gucci store[/url] nspqst

Anonymous said...

All around connection between java your body shape could display their selves as part of your pores and.
An expert in addition , skilled Premium will
have a the history of instruction, subscribers, accreditation, and
recurring school higher than a lot of duration ahead flying " up " the particular
shingle all the fact that became at a very best price!
Sometimes level of caffeine as well as the liquor are certainly not wise in the good prospects for univers.
Ones clanks when driving roll is normally totally removable for convenient to popular taking care of.
Indeed this is one may be groggy at zero remainder as well using last
longer nights night club, there's nothing like a great shot of a darker liquids in us dollar this.

Take a look at my blog post :: Drip Coffee Maker Reviews

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.depressionmedicationhelp.com]prescription isodiur price comparisons
[/url]
Depressionmedicationhelp Pharmacy, Anabolic steroids price list.
[url=http://www.depressionmedicationhelp.com]emthexwte
[/url]
Prices of anabolic steroids. Buy anabolic steroids online. Anabolic steroids best buy.
[url=http://www.depressionmedicationhelp.com]asiergum
[/url]
Where can i buy anabolic steroids? How to buy anabolic steroids? Where to buy anabolic steroids?
[url=http://www.depressionmedicationhelp.com]depressionmedicationhelp Pharmacy[/url]

Anonymous said...

ブランドコピーhttp://www.brandshop9.com 専門店です。弊社にはブランドコピーバッグ、ブランドコピー時計、ブランドコピー財布、ブランドコピー服、ブランドコピーベルト等沢山のスパーブランドコピーが揃えっています。是非ご覧ください。
メール:brandshop8899@yahoo.co.jp
HOME: http://www.brandshop9.com
http://w.livedoor.jp/brandshop9/