Showing posts with label Gender Guidelines. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gender Guidelines. Show all posts

Monday, August 01, 2011

Gomes Sousa—failure to assess gender issues in state protection

Gomes Sousa v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2011 FC 63 (CanLII)

Judge: Justice Noël

Date heard: January 17, 2011

Date decided: January 20, 2011

Counsel for Gomes Sousa: Laura Setzer

Counsel for Minister: Helene Robertson

Place of Hearing: Ottawa, Ontario

The applicant and her son (the minor applicant) were nationals of Brazil. They fled the abuse of the applicant’s former spouse, Marcus, who had substance abuse and other psychiatric issues. The applicant had complained to the police but was told there was little they could do (paras. 1-2). The applicant initially had some support from her parents-in-law, but they blocked the involvement of the police because the father-in-law was himself involved in criminal activity, and he subsequently threatened the applicant (para. 3).

The Court determined that main issue was sufficiently of state protection and the application of the Gender Guidelines (para. 5).

The Court relied on Dean v Canada(Citizenship and Immigration), 2009 FC 772 for the proposition that while a subjective unwillingness to go to the authorities was not, itself, sufficient to rebut state protection, circumstances may be such that they do not. The judge noted that in this case: “proper consideration of the Gender Guidelines may have led to a finding that this reticence to engage the proper authorities was more than subjective” (para. 7). The Court notes that the RPD failed to consider the Gender Guidelines when analyzing the applicant’s failure to approach the police (para. 8).

The RPD found that the applicant’s narrative about the father-in-law was implausible; the judge noted that “implausibility findings must only be made in the clearest of cases” (citing Valtchev v Canada(Minister of Citizenship and Immigration), 2001 FCT 776) (paras. 9-10). The decision concluded:

Hence, the Board’s decision in regards to the sufficiency of state protection is flawed in two aspects. Firstly, it failed to adequately assess the Gender Guidelines in order to fully address the reasons for which state protection was not sought, and secondly, it made an unreasonable plausibility finding, thus depriving the Applicants of a full and proper assessment of the reasons for which state protection was not sought. As such, the decision falls outside the range of acceptable outcomes defensible in fact and in law. The proper remedy is to send the matter for redetermination before a newly constituted panel of the Board. (para. 11)

JUDICIAL REVIEW ALLOWED

Josile—women as a particular social group

Josile v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2011 FC 39 (CanLII)

Judge: Justice Martineau

Date heard: December 8, 2010

Date decided: January 17, 2011

Counsel for Josile: Russell L. Kaplan

Counsel for Minister: Helene Robertson

Place of Hearing: Ottawa, Ontario

The applicant was a female Haitian national who had left Haiti in 2005 and had a refugee claim rejected in the United States, following which she came to Canada and in 2007 made a claim on the basis of political opinion, social group Haitian women, and social group family (para. 3). Her father was a minor local official who had been beaten and threatened for cooperating with the police, and she also feared the level of sexual assault and lack of state protection for women (para. 4).

The Refugee Protection Division (RPD) found that the applicant was not credible regarding her family’s situation (para. 5). Regarding the other grounds, the RPD found that she feared criminals, not politically-motivated harm, and therefore was not protected by the Convention (para. 6). Finally, the RPD found that Haitian women do not face persecution as a particular social group, as any persecution they faced was, again, criminal rather than political (para. 7). She challenged the RPD’s legal analysis of criminality versus political persecution.

Justice Martineau noted that:

The situation of sexual abuse and violence against women in Haiti has recently come to the attention of the Federal Court … In this regard, the Court has cautioned the Board not to import into the definition of a Convention refugee, legal requirements which are specific to section 97 when the Board is assessing whether the fear of persecution is based on a Convention ground in light of section 96 of the Act. (para. 11)

Having reviewed the case law, Justice Martineau noted:

Indeed, a gender-specific claim cannot be rejected simply because the group in question or its members face general oppression and the claimant’s fear of persecution is not supported by an individualized set of facts. Where the claimant has not, himself or herself, experienced the type of persecution, he or she fears, the claimant can use evidence of similarly-situated persons to demonstrate the risk and the unwillingness or inability of the state to protect … (para. 22)

Justice Martineau then turned to similar immigration cases (Dezameau v. Canada(Minister of Citizenship and Immigration), 2010 FC 559 (CanLII)) as well as non-immigration jurisprudence (R. v. Osolin, 1993 CanLII 54 (S.C.C.), [1993] 4 S.C.R. 595) as well as the Immigration and Refugee Board’s own Gender Guidelines, all as authority for the proposition that rape and sexual assault, by their very nature, target women as women (paras. 24-27). Therefore, according to those and other authorities, women fearing sexual assault are a particular social group (paras. 28-32). Therefore the RPD’s finding that nexus had not been established was unreasonable (para. 33).

Justice Martineau also criticized the RPD for making comments about the fact that boys can also be victims of rape (irrelevant, since in that circumstance they are a particular social group in themselves) (para. 34); and stated that “The Court is also appalled by certain gratuitous statements of the Board” about the crime of rape (para. 35).

Unusually, Justice Martineau went further than simply overturning the decision by directing the RPD to consider the new circumstances and risks arising out of events in Haiti since the initial claim was heard (paras. 38-39).

JUDICIAL REVIEW ALLOWED

Thursday, July 28, 2011

Borisovna Abbasova–applicability of Gender Guidelines and failure to consider psychological issues in credibility

Borisovna Abbasova v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2011 FC 43 (CanLII)

Judge: Justice Shore

Date heard: January 10, 2011

Date decided: January 14, 2011

Counsel for Borisovna Abbasova: Denise Feret

Counsel for Minister: Christine Bernard

Place of Hearing: Montréal, Quebec

This was judicial review of a pre-removal risk assessment decision turning on the Gender Guidelines.

Justice Shore opened the reasons with the following emphatic but convoluted statement: “For decision-makers at all levels, procedural fairness sounds a rarely heard alarm, and that alarm must be heard if injustice is not to be done.” (para. 1)

The Applicant was a Russian national who alleged persecution at the hands of her common-law partner, in the form of domestic abuse complicated by the fact that the abuser was a police officer. She further alleged having been mislead by a fraudulent non-lawyer (para. 10).

Her refugee claim was denied in February 2009 (para. 12).

The Applicant filed a PRRA in August 2009, and it was denied in April 2010 (para. 13). A stay of removal was granted in June 2010 (para. 14).

The PRRA officer assigned no weight to the Applicant’s new evidence (para. 15).

The issues were whether the officer erred in not considering the relevant evidence and/or erred in failing to apply the Refugee Protection Division’s Guideline 7 of women fearing gender-related persecution (para. 16).

Justice Shore approved of the PRRA officer’s giving no weight to documentation which, while it post-dated the hearing, “simply echoed the information previously submitted” (paras. 28-30).

However, the PRRA officer also gave no weight to a post-hearing psychological assessment of the Applicant (para. 30). Justice Shore noted that the RPD had found the Applicant not credible, but the psychological report clarified this issue; the PRRA officer ought to have taken into consideration “Possible evidence of the applicant’s inability to testify” (paras. 30-31).

Justice Shore noted that:

It is not for the Court to reassess the evidence submitted to the PRRA officer and that is not what it intends to do; nonetheless, the developments in Ms. Abbasova’s evidence, particularly regarding her psychological condition, could have been considered to be relevant if they had been analyzed. More specifically, in her particular case, as shown, a psychological problem apparently impaired Ms. Abbasova’s ability to testify. That evidence could have been central to the determination of credibility, considering that the RPD and, subsequently, the PRRA officer found Ms. Abbasova not to be credible based on the answers she gave in her testimony. … (para. 37, emphasis in original)

Justice Shore also took into account the new evidence filed by the Applicant in the stay application, notwithstanding the fact that this new medical evidence was not before the PRRA officer (paras. 39-43). Furthermore, the Judge found that even if only the preliminary psychological evidence had been considered by the PRRA officer, the officer night have concluded in the Applicant’s favor or at least that there was an issue of credibility/psychological issues which warranted a hearing (para. 44).

Regarding the Gender Guideline, Justice Shore affirmed their applicability as an “aid” in PRRA decisions (paras. 53-54).

JUDICIAL REVIEW ALLOWED