Showing posts with label torture. Show all posts
Showing posts with label torture. Show all posts

Sunday, February 19, 2012

Cetinkaya—wrong definition of torture, reasonable explanation for lack of corroborating documents

Cetinkaya v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2012 FC 8

http://canlii.ca/en/ca/fct/doc/2012/2012fc8/2012fc8.html

Judge: Justice Russell; Date heard: December 8, 2011; Date decided: January 4, 2012; Counsel for Cetinkaya: Alla Kikinova; Counsel for Minister: Julie Waldman; Place of Hearing: Toronto, Ontario.

The Applicant was a Turkish citizen of Kurdish ethnicity. He alleged a profile as a Kurdish activist who had been tortured by the Turkish authorities. The RPD said that he was not credible, because he had not corroborated his participation in demonstrations with documentary evidence. Furthermore, the RPD found that he had not corroborated his allegations of torture and mistreatment (beatings). This lead the RPD to find that the Applicant was intentionally misleading them. The RPD stated that if the Applicant had been tortured, he would have been more severely hurt.

The Court took issue with a number of the RPD’s findings. The court found that the RPD had unduly relied on the port-of-entry notes to impugn the Applicant’s credibility, noting:

It is an error of the RPD to impugn the credibility of the Applicant on the sole ground that the information provided by the Applicant at the POE interview lacks details. The purpose of the POE interview is to assess whether an individual is eligible and/or admissible to initiate a refugee claim. It is not a part of the claim itself and, consequently, it should not be expected to contain all of the details of the claim (see also Hamdar v Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) 2011 FC 382 at paragraphs 43 through 48, and Jamil v Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) 2006 FC 792 at paragraph 25.) (para. 51)

The Court also found that, contrary to the RPD’s findings, it was not the Applicant who said at the hearing that he was not tortured, but that rather this was a statement of the panel, and furthermore that it was statement based on a lack of understanding of what torture is.

M: So why I am trying to ask you this question. Being beaten is one thing. Being abused by the police is one thing. Torture is a very serious word. So if you were tortured you would have been very severely hurt. But since you just said there was no sign of torture that means you were beaten up by the police, correct.
I: I was beaten, they were beaten to my soft tissues, they were careful not to break my bones, when I gave in answer, and they did not like my answer, they would beat me.

So the Applicant says he was “beaten” by the police. In fact, he explained in some detail what they did to him, including falaka. It is the RPD who says he was not tortured and who makes a desperate and unavailing attempt to make the Applicant agree with its own mistaken view of what torture is. In any event, the Applicant testified that he was severely hurt. The RPD’s logic is that someone can only be tortured if the signs of the torture are visible; being severely hurt without marks on the body is not enough. There is no authority for this conclusion in law or common sense. It is also difficult to understand why the RPD thinks that being beaten up by the police cannot be torture: “Being abused by the police is one thing. Torture is a very serious word.” Torture is a serious word and, accordingly to all the evidence before the RPD, it happened to the Applicant. (paras. 52-53)

The Court noted that the Applicant’s signature at the end of the PIF does not include “declaration at the end of the document that the
information is complete, true and correct”, nor in signing it has a claimant sworn that the narrative if complete or that he has written the narrative himself (para. 55). The Applicant had, however, made such a oath about the fact that he had been tortured (para. 56). The RPD’s findings on credibility were unreasonable and therefore overturned (para. 58).

Furthermore on the RPD’s alternative findings that there was no documentary evidence to support the Applicant’s findings, the Court noted that there was corroborating evidence in that the documentary evidence described the same kind of mass arrests at Newroz as detailed by the Applicant.

Saturday, May 16, 2009

TDS best argument against DADT ever

Clip from May 14

Also, on the torture photo issue, I have to say that while I support transparency, I get that it may not be necessary to release everything, when you've released all the substantive/significant information, releasing more information which won't add to the information, but will add to the outrage, is unnecessary.

Thursday, March 05, 2009

CSIS: Disregarding International Law Since (at least) 2003

So this is horrifying, although I suppose not really surprising:

globeandmail.com: CSIS asked Sudan to arrest Canadian, files reveal

Mr. Abdelrazik is a political refugee who became a Canadian citizen in 1995. In 2003 he was arrested by the Sudanese authorities on the advice of CSIS. In prison for 11 months, he was tortured, and was interrogated by CSIS agents as well as US intelligence operatives. Finally released—because even the Sudanese authorities, well known for their disregard of human rights, could not justify holding him. He was rearrested in October 2005, and held for a further 10 months. At least one of those arrests was at the request of the Canadian government.

Throughout, the Canadian government not only denied Mr. Abdelrazik his rights under international law, including consular protection, they actively obstructed his return to Canada by refusing to issue him emergency travel documents, even after promising to do so as soon as he had arranged a ticket to fly home. They have seized his assets and stated that anyone who gives him money to pay for the ticket is committing a crime and will be charged under terrorist legislation.

The RCMP investigated Mr. Abdelrazik and exonerated him in NOVEMBER 2007. He still can’t come home.

Think Maher Arar was a one-time mistake? Think again.

Wednesday, November 28, 2007

On Waterboarding

Via Joe. My. God., Via - Dan Savage.

"[If] the Bush administration didn’t think [waterboarding] was torture, they ought to do some personal investigation. Someone in the Bush family should actually be waterboarded so they could report on it to George. I said, I didn’t think he would do it, but I suggested Jenna be waterboarded and then she could talk about whether or not she thought it was torture." - Stephen King to Time Magazine.